This article will delve into the allegations of currency manipulation levelled against China, exploring the mechanics of these accusations, the implications on the global economic landscape, and the resultant considerations for family offices, HNWIs, UHNWIs, and their wealth managers. We aim to provide you with a thorough understanding of China’s monetary actions and how they impact the global economy and investment strategies by analysing historical contexts, current trends, and expert opinions.
China’s Economic Rise and Monetary Resilience: A Gaze into Its Foreign Exchange Reservoir
China’s meteoric rise as a manufacturing powerhouse has been nothing short of remarkable. Its aptitude for mass manufacturing has not only propelled its economic growth but also entrenched it as a crucial link in global supply chains. This position has intertwined China’s economic fate with that of other nations, as a disruption in its manufacturing sector has implications for the global supply network. The interdependency underscores China’s pivotal role in the global economic ecosystem.
Moreover, China’s rise has allowed it to amass substantial foreign exchange reserves, further solidifying its influence on global monetary dynamics. China’s foreign exchange reserves have seen some fluctuation in 2023, with figures ranging from USD 3.12 trillion to USD 3.225 trillion across different months. By the end of September 2023, the reserves edged lower to USD 3.12 trillion, down from USD 3.16 trillion in the previous month. This was marked as the lowest level since October 2022, attributed in part to the dollar strengthening against other major currencies.
The State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) of China noted that in August 2023, a surge in the US dollar index led to a general decline in global financial asset prices, consequently affecting China’s foreign exchange reserves. The reserves saw a decline in that month due to the combined effects of currency translation and asset price changes.
Your Wealth, Our Priority: Altoo's Consolidation Power, Secure Document Management, and Seamless Stakeholder Sharing for High Net Worth Individuals. Preview Platform.
Earlier in the year, by the end of May 2023, the reserves were recorded at USD 3.1765 trillion, showing a decrease of USD 28.3 billion, or 0.88%, from the end of April 2023. Global expectations for the fiscal and monetary policies of major economies were one of many factors that influenced this change.
Moreover, Knoema provides a slightly higher figure for China’s foreign exchange reserves. As of August 2023, the reserves were reported to be approximately USD 3.225 trillion, accounting for a significant 33.29% of the world’s total foreign exchange reserves.
These figures reflect China’s substantial economic prowess on the global stage, with its foreign exchange reserves being the largest worldwide. Numerous global economic factors have an impact on the changes in these reserves, which in turn affect international monetary dynamics.
Furthermore, China’s economic policies, especially its monetary manoeuvres, have a broader impact on the global economy. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) report for 2023 mentions a narrowing of China’s current account surplus to 1.3 percent of GDP from 2.1 percent in 2022, indicating a shift in its economic dynamics with potential global ramifications
Historical Context of China’s Currency Manipulation Allegations
China’s economic strategies have long sparked conversations around currency manipulation. At the heart of these discussions lies China’s intervention in the foreign exchange market and unexpected rate settings, which have purportedly been used to undervalue the yuan, bolstering the competitiveness of Chinese exports on the global stage.
Intervention in the Foreign Exchange Market
Historically, China has been known for its proactive measures in the foreign exchange market to maintain the yuan’s value at a level deemed favourable for its economic agenda. By buying or selling foreign currency, China has been able to manage the yuan’s exchange rate against other major currencies. Such interventions have often led to accusations of currency manipulation, as they can skew trade balances in favour of China and pose challenges to global trade dynamics.
Unexpected Rate Settings and Their Impact on the Yuan’s Value
China’s central bank, the People’s Bank of China (PBOC), sets a daily reference rate for the yuan. There have been instances where the PBOC set the daily reference rate at a level weaker than what market forces would dictate, leading to sharp falls in the yuan’s value. These unexpected rate settings have raised concerns among global economic players, as a weaker yuan makes Chinese exports cheaper, potentially leading to trade imbalances.
The US Treasury Department’s Designation and Subsequent Removal of China as a Currency Manipulator
The US Treasury Department’s designation of China as a currency manipulator in August 2019 marked a significant episode in the ongoing discussions surrounding China’s monetary policies. However, this designation was rescinded in January 2020, following China’s commitments to refrain from competitive devaluation and to improve transparency in its foreign exchange practises. The back-and-forth showcased the complex dynamics between the two economic giants and underscored the challenges of conclusively proving currency manipulation.
Challenges in Proving Currency Manipulation and the Intricacies Involved
Proving currency manipulation is a complex affair. It requires clear evidence of intent and a demonstrable impact on trade balances. Because of how complicated currency valuation is and how global economic relationships are linked, it is very hard to show a direct link between a country’s monetary actions and unfair trade advantages. The allegations against China underscore the broader challenges faced by the international community in addressing concerns of currency manipulation in a globalised economy.
Implications on the Global Trade Landscape
Effects on International Trade Balances
The alleged manipulation of the yuan by China could have significant implications for international trade balances. Critics often argue that a devalued yuan functions as both an export subsidy and an import tariff, fostering global trade imbalances. In particular, China’s exchange rate manipulation is seen as a primary hurdle to resolving these imbalances, which can threaten both individual and global economies.
Encouraging Trade Surpluses
By keeping the yuan undervalued, China can potentially foster trade surpluses as its exports become cheaper and imports into China become more expensive. This can lead to burgeoning trade deficits in other countries, particularly in the U.S., as Chinese goods become more competitive price-wise on the global stage.
Impact on Global Supply Chains and Competitiveness of Chinese Exports
Strengthening Export Competitiveness
Currency manipulation can provide China with an unfair advantage in the realm of global trade, allowing the country to artificially sway the benefits of trade in its favour at the expense of others. The competitiveness of Chinese exports is further bolstered in the global market, making China a more attractive manufacturing and export hub.
Disrupting Global Supply Chains
On the flip side, the alleged currency manipulation could disrupt global supply chains. Countries that rely on Chinese imports could face challenges, and the competitiveness of firms in these countries could be undermined as they struggle to compete with cheaper Chinese products.
Retaliatory Measures, Tariffs, and the Ensuing Trade Wars
Escalating Trade Tensions
The accusations of currency manipulation have often led to escalating trade tensions. For instance, the U.S. Treasury Department once designated China as a “currency manipulator,” charging it with devaluing its currency to “gain an unfair competitive advantage in international trade”.
Tariffs and Trade Wars
Retaliatory measures such as tariffs can ensue, sparking trade wars that can further strain international relations and have a ripple effect on the global economy. These retaliatory measures, while aimed at rectifying perceived unfair trade practises, can sometimes exacerbate the situation, leading to a cycle of tit-for-tat measures that can be detrimental to global trade.
China’s Monetary Policy: A Closer Look
China’s Commitments to Refrain from Competitive Devaluation
China, along with the United States, has committed to abstaining from competitive currency devaluations. This commitment was reiterated in a bilateral agreement, as both nations acknowledged the importance of maintaining an orderly transition in their respective foreign exchange markets.
Recent Appreciation of the Renminbi (RMB) and Its Potential Underlying Causes
01 Strengthening of the Yuan
The Renminbi (RMB) or yuan, experienced a significant appreciation against the US dollar in recent times. The currency strengthened by 4,500 basis points since November 2022, indicating a bullish economic recovery fueled by investor optimism and policy support measures aimed at bolstering economic resilience.
02 Rapid Appreciation
During a trading period extending over a week in 2023, the RMB exchange rate appreciated by more than or close to 2%, reaching a level rarely seen in history. Various financial institutions forecasted a recovery for the yuan in 2023, with estimates pointing towards a gradual appreciation throughout the year.
03 Underlying Causes
The rapid depreciation of the renminbi in previous periods can be attributed to several factors, including:
- Lockdowns in China since March 2022 have led to a significant drop in exports
- A rise in the US dollar index due to Federal Reserve’s interest rate hikes
- Increased demand for the US dollar as a safe-haven asset amid geopolitical uncertainties, particularly the Russia-Ukraine conflict
Transparency and Regulatory Developments in China’s Foreign Exchange Market
01 New Regulatory Framework
In a sweeping reform, China announced the establishment of a new financial regulatory body aimed at consolidating oversight to close loopholes across various agencies monitoring the financial services industry, including the foreign exchange market. This new entity, named the National Financial Regulatory Administration, will replace the China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission (CBIRC) and bring industry supervision under a unified body directly reporting to the State Council. This initiative is part of a broader regulatory overhaul aimed at reining in systemic risks and enhancing oversight over large corporate and financial institutions.
02 Strengthened Supervision
The new regulatory setup aims to “strengthen institutional supervision, supervision of behaviours, and supervision of functions,” ensuring a more robust and continuous oversight mechanism. Under the existing setup, regulatory functions were dispersed among various bodies, including the People’s Bank of China (PBOC) and the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC). The new arrangement centralises these functions, allowing for better coordination and oversight, particularly in the foreign exchange market.
03 Development of Foreign Exchange Derivatives Market
As China transitions towards a more flexible exchange rate, efforts are underway to develop its foreign exchange (FX) derivatives markets to meet the growing hedging needs associated with greater exchange rate fluctuations. This development is essential to accommodate the changing dynamics of China’s foreign exchange market and to provide necessary financial instruments for managing exchange rate risks.
